Earth’s atmosphere may have experienced major increases in oxygen levels much earlier than traditionally believed, according to a new review of geological evidence that challenges the conventional understanding of the planet’s oxygenation history.
The findings suggest that two major increases in atmospheric oxygen occurred around 1.3 billion to 1.0 billion years ago and 440 million to 410 million years ago, preceding corresponding changes in ocean oxygen levels.
Geochemists Haiyang Wang and Chao Li of Chengdu University of Technology reviewed geological records, including sulfate preserved in sedimentary rocks, to reconstruct the history of atmospheric oxygen.
For most of Earth’s history, atmospheric oxygen levels were too low to support wildfires. However, charcoal preserved in rocks indicates that oxygen had reached levels capable of sustaining fires by around 420 million years ago, approximately three-quarters of today’s atmospheric level.
A different record of ancient oxygen
Scientists have traditionally relied on marine rocks, minerals, isotopes and trace metals to estimate ancient oxygen levels. However, these records primarily reflect ocean chemistry, which is influenced by nutrient supplies, biological activity, water circulation and the shape of ocean basins.
Wang and Li examined sulfate as a potentially more direct indicator of atmospheric conditions. When sulfide minerals oxidise, atmospheric oxygen leaves a distinctive isotopic signature in sulfate, which can be preserved in sedimentary rocks.
This evidence provides researchers with a way to reconstruct changes in atmospheric oxygen over geological timescales.
The Great Oxidation Event, which occurred around 2.4 billion to 2.1 billion years ago, remains an established milestone in Earth’s history.
Cyanobacteria had been producing oxygen in shallow coastal waters long before this event. However, much of the oxygen was consumed through reactions with minerals and gases before it could accumulate in the atmosphere.
Eventually, oxygen production exceeded consumption, allowing atmospheric levels to rise.
Oceans may have responded later
The researchers’ findings challenge the conventional timing of two later oxygenation events.
The Neoproterozoic Oxygenation Event, traditionally dated to around 800 million to 500 million years ago, and the Paleozoic Oxygenation Event, generally placed between 420 million and 360 million years ago, may have largely reflected changes in ocean chemistry rather than the initial rise of atmospheric oxygen.
According to the sulfate evidence, atmospheric oxygen levels had already increased approximately 200 million years before the first corresponding ocean changes and around 30 million years before the second.
The study also suggests that some ocean oxygenation events may have temporarily reduced atmospheric oxygen.
As oxygen entered the oceans, chemical reactions involving stored organic carbon and sulfur compounds consumed it, potentially lowering the amount remaining in the atmosphere.
The ‘boring billion’ revisited
The findings could also reshape understanding of the so-called ‘boring billion’, a period between roughly one billion and 410 million years ago that was long considered relatively uneventful in terms of major environmental changes.
Modelling based on the sulfate evidence suggests that atmospheric oxygen during the mid-Proterozoic may have remained extremely low, at just 0.1 to 1 per cent of today’s level.
Under such conditions, photosynthesis in shallow waters likely supplied much of the available oxygen locally, while the deep ocean remained largely oxygen-free.
The findings highlight the complex relationship between Earth’s atmosphere and oceans and suggest that their oxygenation histories may have followed different timelines.